Sell Tiffany Jewelry for a Fashionable Profit

June 24th, 2024

Upgrade Your Style, Upgrade Your Wallet: Sell Tiffany Jewelry for a Fashionable Profit

Tiffany & Company is a luxury jewelry brand with a long and colorful history. If you own a Tiffany and no longer wear it, you can sell Tiffany jewelry for a profit and upgrade your style for another piece that suits you more. 

Tiffany & Co. is an iconic American jewelry brand that has stood the test of time. Due to its lasting legacy, Tiffany & Co. jewelry has a high resale value. So, if you no longer wear your Tiffany engagement ring, sell it!

This blog will uncover what you can do with unwanted Tiffany jewelry, where to sell Tiffany jewelry, and how to sell Tiffany jewelry. We will also discuss how to determine the worth of your Tiffany.

Table of Contents


What to Know About Tiffany & Co

What is an Authentic Tiffany Jewelry? 

Understanding the Market of Pre-Owned Tiffany Jewelry

Where to Sell Tiffany Jewelry

Why Sell Your Tiffany Jewelry to Sell Us Your 

Preowned Silver Band: Sell Tiffany Jewelry
Wondering how to sell Tiffany jewelry? like your precious Tiffany & Co. Preowned Streamerica band with Diamonds 0.20 carat in 18k white gold. Size 8.5.

What to Know About Tiffany & Co

Nothing is as exciting as opening a Tiffany blue box and finding an exquisitely crafted piece of jewelry!

Every iconic brand has an amazing story. In 1837, a young New Yorker, Charles Tiffany, opened a “stationery and fancy goods” store on Broadway-Tiffany, Young, and Ellis. In 1853, Charles had complete control of the store and renamed it Tiffany & Co to establish its emphasis on selling jewelry.

Tiffany was well-known among New York socialites for its stylish fine jewelry. Tiffany’s modern American style distinguished itself from the overstated Victorian trend, such as enormously jewel-encrusted rings and heavily embellished brooches. 

Two significant years stand out in Tiffany’s close to 200 years of existence. The company’s purchase of a 200-carat yellow diamond from Africa took the world by storm; the introduction of the modern engagement ring in 1886 highlighted the sparkle of the diamond gearing away from Victorian bezel settings. 

In 2021, LVMH Moët Hennessy Louis Vuitton acquired a majority stake in Tiffany & Co. However, Tiffany continues to operate as an independent subsidiary and is still headquartered in New York City. 

Tiffany & Co. has over 300 stores worldwide in many countries other than the United States, including Canada, Latin America, Europe, Japan, and Asia-Pacific. The company’s product line includes fine jewelry, sterling silver, crystal, porcelain, stationery, personal accessories, haute couture fragrances, and leather goods. 

While Tiffany's fine jewelry styles may have changed through the years, one thing never did: the iconic Tiffany blue box. This desirable Robin’s egg blue box embraced by a white satin ribbon is as unique as its jewelry. 

Everyone all over the world dreams of owning Tiffany jewelry. So, if you have unwanted Tiffany jewelry, upgrade your wallet by considering selling your Tiffany jewelry. 

Tiffany & Co. is one of the most beloved and trusted luxury jewelry brands, with Tiffany engagement rings being the most popular diamond ring brands.

Preowned Tiffany Gold Band for Jewelry Buyer
Looking for a trusted preowned Jewelry buyer to sell your Tiffany & Co. wedding band 1837 anniversary band?

What is an Authentic Tiffany Jewelry?

When choosing to sell Tiffany jewelry, please know your piece will be evaluated if it is authentic. Tiffany & Co. is known for producing luxury fine jewelry with high-quality craftsmanship, iconic designs, and the use of precious materials. 

Look for these elements to ensure what you have is authentic Tiffany & Co. jewelry. 

Quality and Craftsmanship

Tiffany & Co. is known for its extraordinary craftsmanship and attention to detail. Authentic Tiffany jewelry exhibits high-quality construction and finishing. 


Tiffany jewelry carries specific hallmarks, including the Tiffany & Co stamp, or the metal purity stamp such as “925” for sterling silver. 

Logo and Engraving

Authentic Tiffany jewelry comes with the Tiffany & Co logo or brand name and other relevant markings engraved with precision. 

Packaging and Documentation

Genuine Tiffany jewelry typically comes with original packaging (the iconic Tiffany blue box), certificates of authenticity, and receipts. 

Work with a reputable jewelry buyer who specializes in buying pre-owned Tiffany jewelry to ensure you get the best price when you sell Tiffany jewelry

Understanding the Market of Pre-Owned Tiffany Jewelry

Tiffany & Co. jewelry has a high resale value and is classic, popular, and in high demand. Tiffany jewelry is a timeless symbol of quality craftsmanship, the finest materials, and timeless designs; thus, they retain their value over time. Why? Well-experienced master artisans cut Tiffany diamonds and are 100 % conflict-free (ethically sourced). 

Tiffany & Co. engages in continuous advertising and marketing campaigns. Thus, “Tiffany” has been synonymous with luxury. As a result, your Tiffany tends to hold its resale value. A Tiffany in good condition (minimal wear and tear) can fetch top dollars in the secondary market. 

Where to Sell Tiffany Jewelry

A jewelry buyer is always interested in buying your Tiffany jewelry because of its high demand. However, you must avoid getting ripped off when selling to the wrong jewelry buyer.

If you want to sell Tiffany jewelry, you have several brick-and-mortar stores and online options. Selling your Tiffany jewelry to pawn shops, local jewelry stores, or auction houses can be a convenient choice. However, they will not offer you the true value of your jewelry since they are always after higher profits.  

Sell Us Your is the best place to sell Tiffany jewelry. Continue reading and discover how to sell Tiffany jewelry to Sell Us Your

Why Sell Your Tiffany Jewelry to Sell Us Your, the online buying platform of Gray & Sons Jewelers is a professional jewelry buyer. Founded in 1980, Sell Us Your Jewelry has qualified jewelry appraisers, sales specialists, and six Swiss-trained watchmakers with a combined experience of over 150 years. This ensures you get top dollars for your Tiffany jewelry. 

With, you will have a unique and satisfying selling experience because we offer the following: 

A Convenient and Fast Selling Method has a convenient, straightforward four-step selling process.

  1. Request for a free quote to receive an initial offer.  Our initial offer will be based on your uploaded description and photos of your item. 
  2. If you accept our initial offer, send us your item via registered mail using the Easy Ship Box. 
  3. We will conduct a thorough and final physical jewelry inspection and offer you a final offer. 
  4. We will send you immediate payment via check or wire transfer if you accept our final offer. 

A Transparent and Secure Selling Experience

You can contact us through email, telephone, or chat for any questions you may have throughout the selling process. We are insured and bonded to ensure your jewelry is safe with us.  

The Most Value for Your Tiffany has qualified gemologists knowledgeable about Tiffany & Co. jewelry and can assess your Tiffany jewelry to ensure you get the most value. 

Reliable and Trustworthy

Sell Us Your is a reliable and trustworthy Tiffany jewelry buyer. Our A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau is a testament to this claim. 

If you have any pieces from these top Tiffany & Co Jewelry collections gathering dust in your home, request a free quote now! We will buy your jewelry regardless of its condition, but it will be reflected in the purchase price. 

We buy Tiffany & Co. necklaces, rings, bracelets, earrings, Stud earrings and pendants. In any materials such as gold, sterling silver, rose gold, white gold, platinum, and copper. Also, we buy them with any of the following gemstones: diamonds, pearls, rubies, sapphires, aquamarines, turquoise, and colored gemstones. 


  • Trinity Save the Wild
  • Tiffany T
  • Tiffany Keys
  • Paloma Picasso
  • Tiffany HardWear
  • Tiffany Victoria
  • Elsa Peretti
  • Tiffany 1837
  • Return to Tiffany
  • Tiffany Setting
  • Diamonds by the Yard
  • Loving Heart 
  • Graffiti

Sell your Tiffany jewelry now. Request a free quote to know how much your jewelry is worth. You can then use the funds to buy an item that suits your style!



Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer an estate jewelry, watch and sterling silver specialist with a professional career spanning over 50 years, including an impressive 30 years career at Gray and Sons Jewelers, the premier destination for selling, buying, repairing and consigning luxury watches and estate jewelry… Read more About the Story of Claudine Faifer




What would you like to sell?

No Selected images
* Max. file size: 40 MB, Max. files: 5.

click here to