The Guide to Selling Tiffany Jewelry Successfully

April 10th, 2024

Unblocking the Brilliance: How to Sell Tiffany & Co. Jewelry

With a legacy of over 180 years, Tiffany & Co. has become synonymous with sophistication and exceptional quality. If you plan to sell Tiffany jewelry, whether due to a change in taste, lifestyle, or other reasons, you are not alone. 

Whether you have antique or vintage Tiffany jewelry or one from their latest collection and want to part with it, you may wonder how to sell Tiffany jewelry. 

This blog probes into the world of selling Tiffany jewelry. It aims to guide you through the best practices to ensure you unlock the maximum value of your extraordinary pieces. 


Sparkle and Style: Selling Tiffany Jewelry Ring Masterpieces
If you're wondering how to sell Tiffany jewelry, this exquisite piece of Tiffany & Co. Schlumberger diamonds eternity band in 18k and platinum. Sixteen round brilliant cut diamonds total approx. 1.14 carat, could be your answer.


Understanding the Value of Tiffany Jewelry

Tiffany & Co., founded in New York by Charles Lewis Tiffany in 1837,  boasts a wide range of luxury jewelry. Tiffany has become the most iconic jewelry brand in the US. 

 Owning a Tiffany means owning jewelry with the following qualities:

  • Timeless Elegance. Tiffany & Co. is best known for its classic and lasting designs. Its collections have maintained their appeal for generations, making them timeless and sought-after. 
  • Exceptional Craftsmanship. Each Tiffany piece is crafted using high-quality materials, expert craftsmanship, and unique design elements, contributing to the enduring value of Tiffany jewelry. 
  • Brand Recognition. The Tiffany brand is recognized worldwide and associated with prestige and luxury. The brand’s reputation adds significant value to Tiffany's pieces, making it highly desirable in the resale market. 


Most of Tiffany and Co.’s jewelry comes with a stamp of the company’s mark and a marking signifying the metal’s purity. Every Tiffany jewelry also comes in the brand’s iconic Blue Box.

Owning Tiffany & Co. jewelry is holding an iconic piece in the world of luxury. Knowing where to sell Tiffany jewelry cannot be overstated. 

Tiffany jewelry is classic and popular and often retains value; sometimes, it even appreciates.  The best place to sell Tiffany jewelry offers: competitive prices, transparent process and fast payments. 

Challenges of Selling Tiffany Jewelry 

Selling your pre-owned Tiffany jewelry can be a rewarding endeavor. However, it also comes with its challenges, and navigating them when you sell Tiffany and Co. jewelry is crucial for a successful and satisfying selling experience. 

  • Emotional Attachment. You may find it difficult to detach your personal feelings from the selling process. 
  • Authentication Concerns.  Providing proof of authenticity, such as original documents, receipts, or certificates, and the iconic Tiffany blue box, will be very helpful in the selling process. 
  • Value Perception. Getting the value you deserve for your Tiffany jewelry may also be challenging. However, a Tiffany is a classic with a high resale value and is always a sought-after piece. You can get a good return for your Tiffany when you sell to a knowledgeable jewelry buyer who will recognize the true value of your piece. 
  • Limited Resale Channels. Finding reputable and trustworthy channels to sell Tiffany jewelry can be challenging. 

Careful planning and a proactive approach can help you overcome potential obstacles when finding the best place to sell Tiffany jewelry. At Sell Us Your we understand these challenges which is why we offer a convenient and transparent selling process. 


Where to Sell Tiffany Jewelry

Where to sell Tiffany jewelry influences getting the most value for your piece. You want a successful selling process and a good experience regardless of why you are selling Tiffany jewelry. Thus, it is why at Sell Us Your Jewelry we have the following qualities for our customers to feel confident when selling to us: 

  • A professional and reliable  environment. We have been trusted worldwide for over 43 years. 
  • Expertise in the true value of your Tiffany jewelry. 
  • Offer a hassle-free and straightforward selling process. 
  • Offer a fair and competitive price for your piece. 

You may think of other options for where to sell Tiffany jewelry like the ones below: 

  • Pawnshops. You can get instant payment, but they will pay you the lowest price for your Tiffany. 
  • Jewelry Stores. Jewelry stores may have staff knowledgeable in luxury jewelry. However brick and mortar jewelry stores may lack necessary tools to fully recognize,  appreciate, and re market your item. 
  • Direct Online Marketplaces. You may attempt to sell Tiffany jewelry at online marketplaces, but the process can be tedious because you must deal with each prospective buyer. 
  • Auction Houses. The online and physical auction houses also offer convenience in selling your Tiffany; however, they may charge high fees and have a lengthy process or even undersell your pieces. 

These options do not priotize you as a seller. At Sell Us Your we make sure you are a part of the entire selling process. Since we are an online platform we provide a convenient process. In addition we have a knowledgeable staff that will answer all your questions or concerns.


Luxury Unveiled: Sell Tiffany Jewelry with Confidence
Tiffany & Co. 1999, Angela Cummings Tahitian grey pearl (10 x 10.5mm) and diamonds drop earrings set in 18K yellow gold & Platinum. Round brilliant cut diamonds total approx. weight 2.50 carats. Perfect for us jewelry buyer. 


Tips for Maximizing the Value of Your Tiffany Jewelry

Preparing your Tiffany & Co. jewelry for resale requires attention to detail. Here are some practical tips to help you get the best results. 

  • Do Not Clean Your Jewelry. You may think that cleaning your jewelry is a great option so it looks nicer but is actually best not to clean it. Cleaning your jewelry can deter its value as you may accidentally scratch it or it may can ruined if you use the wrong products. Jewelry buyers like us at Sell Us Your we like the jewelry better as it is. 
  • Gather Documentation. The original Tiffany & Co. packaging, the iconic Blue Box, and certificates of authenticity can add value and authenticity to your piece. Check for the correct hallmarks and engravings specific to authentic Tiffany & Co. jewelry. 

Combining these strategies can help you effectively leverage Tiffany & Co.’s prestige to maximize the value of your pre-owned Tiffany. 


Navigating the Selling Process

Selling Tiffany jewelry to online marketplaces or individuals involves numerous steps:  

  1. Initial evaluation. 
  2. Professional appraisal.  
  3. Cleaning and Restoration
  4. Taking clear and high-quality photographs 
  5. Researching the market to determine a fair and competitive price. 
  6. Creating a detailed listing with a comprehensive and accurate description of Tiffany jewelry. 
  7. Choosing a reputable online platform or marketplace to list your item. 
  8. Responding to inquiries from potential buyers. 
  9. Finalizing the transaction and receiving payment. 
  10. Safely packing and shipping the Tiffany jewelry. 

However, you can simplify start the selling process with us Sell Us Your It only takes 4 easy steps: 

  1. Request for a free quote to determine how much your Tiffany is worth. Share as much information and photos of your item to receive a more accurate valuation. 
  2. If you agree on the initial offer for your Tiffany, send your piece to Sell Us Your using the Easy Ship Box. 
  3. A more thorough physical evaluation will be done on your piece to determine its condition, authenticity, and final market value. 
  4. You will receive a check or wire transfer payment if you agree to the final offer. 

Sell Us Your, Gray & Sons Jewelers' buying platform, we are  reliable and trustworthy. We have been buying and selling pre-owned luxury jewelry, including Tiffany & Co. pieces, since 1980. We are the top Tiffany & Co. jewelry buyer in Miami and the U.S. 

Tiffany & Co. jewelry has become associated with elegance, exceptional craftsmanship and quality, and timeless designs. Tiffany pieces tend to hold their value well over time. Thus, it can be lucrative to sell Tiffany jewelry. 


What Is My Tiffany Jewelry Worth? 

For Tiffany & Co. jewelry, the average retail prices typically range from $200 for simple pieces like the Return to Tiffany line, up to well over $100,000 for exquisite diamond engagement rings and high jewelry creations. At Gray & Sons, our pre-owned Tiffany & Co. jewelry ranges between $350 - $45,000. Popular jewelry includes the The Schlumberger collection($10,000-$85,000 average retail price),The Tiffany T collection($5,000-$40,000 average retail price)The Tiffany HardWear Collection($5,000-$30,000 average retail price)


Visit Sell Us Your and get the most value when you sell Tiffany jewelry! See Us Last!



Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer an estate jewelry, watch and sterling silver specialist with a professional career spanning over 50 years, including an impressive 30 years career at Gray and Sons Jewelers, the premier destination for selling, buying, repairing and consigning luxury watches and estate jewelry… Delve Deeper into Claudine Faifer's Full and Fascinating Story





What would you like to sell?

No Selected images
* Max. file size: 40 MB, Max. files: 5.

click here to