
April 2nd, 2026
How to Sell Tiffany & Co. Jewelry: A Comprehensive Guide
Are you considering parting ways with your beloved Tiffany & Co. jewelry? Whether you're looking to upgrade your collection, need extra cash, or simply want to declutter, selling your Tiffany pieces can be a rewarding experience. In this guide, we'll walk you through the process of selling Tiffany & Co. jewelry, ensuring you get the best value for your precious items.
Understanding the Value of Tiffany & Co. Jewelry
Tiffany & Co. has been synonymous with luxury and elegance for over 180 years. Their pieces are not just jewelry; they're investments. When you decide to sell Tiffany & Co. jewelry, it's crucial to understand what makes these pieces so valuable:
- Brand Reputation: The Tiffany & Co. name carries significant weight in the luxury market.
- Quality of Materials: Tiffany uses only the finest gemstones and metals in their creations.
- Craftsmanship: Each piece is meticulously crafted, often by hand.
- Iconic Designs: Many Tiffany collections, like the Return to Tiffany and Paper Flowers, are instantly recognizable.

Popular Tiffany & Co. Collections to Sell
When looking to sell Tiffany & Co. jewelry, certain collections tend to be in high demand:
- Return to Tiffany Collection: This iconic line features heart-shaped pendants and bracelets.
- Tiffany T Collection: Known for its minimalist, modern designs.
- Elsa Peretti Designs: Celebrated for their fluid, organic shapes.
- Paper Flowers Collection: A contemporary line inspired by flower petals.
- Tiffany Keys: Symbolic and versatile pieces that remain popular.

1. Gather Documentation
Before you start the selling process, collect all relevant documentation for your Tiffany pieces:
- Original receipts
- Certificates of authenticity
- Appraisal documents
- Packaging and boxes
These documents can significantly increase the value and credibility of your items.
2. Get a Professional Appraisal
While you may have an idea of your jewelry's worth, a professional appraisal is crucial. Look for a certified appraiser who specializes in luxury jewelry. They can provide an accurate valuation based on:
- Current market trends
- Condition of the piece
- Rarity and demand
3. Choose the Right Buyer
When it comes to selling Tiffany & Co. jewelry, not all buyers are created equal. Consider these options:
- Reputable Jewelry Buyers: Specialized buyers like Gray & Sons Jewelery have extensive experience with luxury brands.
- Auction Houses: For rare or high-value pieces, auction houses can sometimes fetch premium prices.
- Online Marketplaces: While convenient, be cautious and ensure secure transactions.
4. Prepare Your Jewelry
Before presenting your jewelry to potential buyers:
- Clean your pieces carefully
- Address any minor repairs
- Ensure all parts are intact (e.g., clasps, settings)
A well-maintained piece can command a higher price.

Types of Tiffany & Co. Jewelry You Can Sell
You can sell various types of Tiffany & Co. jewelry, including:
- Tiffany & Co. Rings: From engagement rings to fashion rings
- Tiffany & Co. Bracelets: Including the popular Return to Tiffany bracelets
- Tiffany & Co. Necklaces: Pendants, chains, and statement pieces
- Tiffany & Co. Earrings: Studs, hoops, and drop earrings
- Tiffany & Co. Pendants: Including the iconic heart pendants

Maximizing Your Return
To get the best price when you sell Tiffany & Co. jewelry:
- Timing is Key: Keep an eye on market trends. Precious metal prices fluctuate, which can affect your jewelry's value.
- Condition Matters: Well-maintained pieces often fetch higher prices.
- Complete Sets: If you have matching pieces or original packaging, include them to potentially increase value.
- Be Realistic: While Tiffany & Co. holds its value well, be prepared for some depreciation from the original retail price.
How it works
ONLINE PROCESS
1. Request a Quote Find out how much is your watch or jewelry worth? The more information & photos you share with us the more accurate the market valuation will be. Upon completion of an online submission our experts will contact you with an initial quote.
2. Send Items for Inspection We will provide Easy Ship box and packing materials with our address label. Simply take it to the post office. Send it via registered mail and fully insured*, and we will refund your cost of shipping and insurance upon purchase, up to a maximum of $100, provided you submit proper documentation.
3. Receive Payment Once the inspection is complete and details of the transaction are confirmed, you will quickly receive your payment via check or bank wire.
IN-STORE PROCESS
1. Walk-In our Showroom No appointment necessary. Visit our store at 9595 Harding Avenue, Surfside, FL 33154. Across the street form world-famous Bal Harbour Shops.
2. In-House Inspection Jewelry and Watch buying experts along with in-house master trained watchmakers on-site will perform an in-house inspection for an immediate evaluation.
3. Receive Payment Once the inspection is complete and details of the transaction are confirmed, you will quickly receive your payment via check or bank wire.
* Be sure to protect your valuables with adequate shipping insurance. IF YOU OVERPAY FOR YOUR INSURANCE, IT IS NOT OUR RESPONSIBILITY TO COVER THE EXCESS AMOUNT.DO NOT USE FEDEX OR UPS, AS THEY DO NOT INSURE JEWELRY OR WATCHES.** Gray and Sons is not responsible for shipping and insurance cost to return counterfeit watches or jewelry shall the client wishes to get them returned.
What Are You Looking To Sell?

Sell your watch
How much is your watch worth?

Sell your jewelry
How much is your jewelry worth?

Sell your diamond
How much is your diamond worth?

Sell your sterling silver
How much is your silver worth?
About Us | Sell Us Your Jewelry
Call Us Now: 305 770 6955
The Purchasing and Consignment Division of Gray & Sons

Be the first to know | SEE OUR CATALOG
