Where to Sell Your Preowned Tiffany Jewelry Online

March 8th, 2024

How to Successfully Sell Your Tiffany Jewelry Online

Tiffany and Co. has some of the most well-designed and crafted pieces of jewelry in the world! If you never wear your Tiffany jewelry or need of some cash, you may want to sell tiffany jewelry. 


Tiffanny & Co. Vannerie collection necklace in 18K yellow gold
Tiffanny & Co. Vannerie collection necklace in 18K yellow gold


About Tiffany & Co. 

Tiffany is one of the most beloved, iconic, and trusted brands in the jewelry industry. 

Charles Tiffany, a young New Yorker opened a stationary and fancy goods store on Broadway in the 1830s. During that time, the store was patronized by New York socialites because of its stylish fine jewelry. 

Tiffany jewelry was unique because of its modern American style making it stand out. This jewelry maker shocked the world in 1878 when it bought an amazing 200-carat yellow diamond from South Africa. 

In 1886, Tiffany & Co came up with the modern engagement ring focusing on the radiance of the diamond. Today, Tiffany engagement rings remain the most coveted branded diamond rings.

Tiffany & Co jewelry created several styles of jewelry through the years but one thing is constant – the Tiffany blue box! The robin’s egg blue box is perfectly embraced by a white satin box. 

Tiffany & Co prides itself on being the highest brand of luxurious jewelry because of:

  • Brand heritage
  • Product quality
  • Lasting appeal
  • Exclusivity
  • Status
  • Feel-good factor


With an awesome history, women worldwide dream of owning a piece of jewelry from Tiffany & Co. This is good news if you want to sell tiffany jewelry

Tiffany & Co. wedding band 1837 anniversary band
Tiffany & Co. wedding band 1837 anniversary band


Tiffany Jewelry Resale Value

There are many reasons you may want to sell tiffany jewelry. 

  • Your marriage has ended and you no longer want to hold on to your engagement ring with many painful memories attached to it. 
  • You inherited a Tiffany diamond ring that does not fit your taste or style. 
  • You want to upgrade to an even better Tiffany jewelry. 

When you own Tiffany jewelry, you have a classic and popular piece! It comes with a strong resale value and is always in demand. This means you can get a good return selling tiffany jewelry. 

Why do Tiffany jewelry  retain their resale value more than any other branded jewelry? 

  • The Tiffany brand is associated with high quality, timeless design, and luxury. 
  • There is an ongoing high demand for Tiffany jewelry. 


A Tiffany engagement ring or any Tiffany jewelry that is in good condition can bring a pretty good resale value. 

Where to Sell Tiffany & Co Jewelry

No matter your reason for selling tiffany jewelry, you would want to get the best price possible for your piece. 

Here are some things to consider when you are ready to sell your Tiffany jewelry:

  • You want to make sure you sell tiffany jewelry to a trustworthy buyer. 
  • You want the selling process to be straightforward and hassle-free. 
  • You want to work with someone knowledgeable about the true value of your Tiffany jewelry. 
  • You want to make sure you get a fair price for your Tiffany. 

 You have some options where to sell tiffany jewelry and ensure a smooth transaction. 

  • Jewelry stores. This is a good option but since jewelry stores have a high overhead, they will offer you a lower resale value. 
  • Pawnshops. They will give you quick cash but will pay you the lowest amount for your Tiffany. 
  • Online. This is the most convenient and simplest way to sell your Tiffany. Some of the most common ways for selling tiffany jewelry online include: 


When selling tiffany jewelry online, you need to ensure you are dealing with a reputable online buyer. Here are some of your options: 

  • Online Auction House. Several online auction houses accept extremely rare and high-value Tiffany jewelry. Online auction houses are convenient but it entails high fees and a lengthy process while not guaranteeing a sale. 
  • Online Auction Sites. These sites offer user-friendly ways to list your items. However, it can be time-consuming and challenging to accurately price your item because you do not have the expertise and knowledge. 
  • Online Specialist Buyer. Online specialist buyers offer easy and quick online service for selling tiffany jewelry. These buyers can ensure you get the best price for your jewelry. 


Tiffany & Co. "True Narrow" diamond ring in 18k rose gold
Tiffany & Co. "True Narrow" diamond ring in 18k rose gold


How to Sell your Tiffany Jewelry Online

It pays to only sell tiffany jewelry online to a professional and reputable jewelry buyer. However, it can be daunting to choose the right online buyer. 

  • Choose a company with a strong reputation. It is less risky to deal with a company with many years of buying experience and with a good reputation. 
  • Read reviews of previous clients. Avoid buyers with many negative reviews.
  •  Check ratings from the Better Business Bureau. This ensures the legitimacy of the company. 
  • Make sure your item will be safe and secure. Safety and security are of utmost importance when mailing your item to the buyer. Make sure the company opens your item on camera. It should also be insured.
  • There should be no hidden fees. Beware of companies that will charge unexpected fees.


This is the usual process when selling tiffany jewelry online: 

  1. Get an online quote for your Tiffany jewelry. Upload a photo of your item and include a description.  
  2. Mail your Tiffany to the company. 
  3. The company will verify your item. 
  4. You will be contacted for an offer (buyer price or consignment terms). 

Before requesting an online quote, you will be in a better position if you research everything about your Tiffany jewelry. 


How to Get the Best Price for your Tiffany & Co Jewelry

Here are important things you need to do to ensure you get the best price when selling tiffany jewelry. 

  • Clean your Tiffany jewelry so it looks as appealing as when it was first purchased. 
  •  Have in hand all elements that came with your Tiffany
    • Tiffany Blue Box
    • Tiffany bag
    • Certificate of Authenticity
    • Original Receipt
    • Warranty card
    • Information booklet

If you no longer have the original box and documentation, you can contact Tiffany & Co and request for the official paperwork if you are the original purchase. 

If that is not possible, have your Tiffany jewelry appraised to confirm it is genuine and to also know the fair market value. 

Without the original box and papers, the sale price of your Tiffany jewelry can be reduced by as much as 10%. 


Final Thoughts

Selling tiffany jewelry online is the best way to sell your item. Make sure you deal with a professional, knowledgeable, and reputable Tiffany jewelry buyer so you can get the best possible price for your item. 

Sellusyourjewelry.com combines the best of two  worlds. You can sell online from the comfort of your home or you can visit their showroom in Miami in person. They have been in business for 43 years serving Miami, Florida and nationwide. 




Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer an estate jewelry, watch and sterling silver specialist with a professional career spanning over 50 years, including an impressive 30 years career at Gray and Sons Jewelers, the premier destination for selling, buying, repairing and consigning luxury watches and estate jewelry… Discover Claudine Faifer's Complete Captivating History





What would you like to sell?

No Selected images
* Max. file size: 40 MB, Max. files: 5.

click here to