Selling Tiffany Jewelry: Preparing Tiffany Jewelry for Sale

March 8th, 2024

Selling Tiffany Jewelry: How to Prepare your Tiffany Jewelry For sale

sell your tiffany and co wedding band
sell your tiffany and co wedding band


If you own a piece of Tiffany jewelry and, for any reason, you no longer need it, sell it! Tiffany & Co jewelry holds a lot of value so selling tiffany jewelry will give you a good return when you prepare your item well. 

Your Tiffany & Co jewelry comes with a high resale value because it is a timeless piece making it always in demand. 

Selling tiffany jewelry can be relatively easy because it is a highly recognizable classic brand extremely popular with consumers.  A Tiffany piece of jewelry such as a diamond ring, a charm bracelet, a necklace, a pendant, or a pair of earrings, captures the essence of well-crafted and luxurious jewelry. 

Tiffany & Co does not buy back their jewelry. 


How to Prepare your Tiffany Jewelry for Sale

After deciding to sell your Tiffany piece, get down to work and prepare your Tiffany jewelry to ensure you get the highest possible price. 


sell your tiffany and co engagement ring
sell your tiffany and co engagement ring


How to sell Tiffany jewelry? For example, if you are selling your Tiffany Diamond Engagement ring, you may start with gathering all paperwork: certificates, valuation reports and original packaging, if you still have it. 

The Tiffany & Co. Diamond Certificate

This certifies the integrity, authenticity, and grades of your Tiffany diamond and is backed by the  Full Time Warranty. 

Your Diamond Certificate includes pertinent information such as the SKU number and the serial number of your jewelry. The serial number is also hidden in your ring. The Certificate comes in a watermarked sheet and is placed in a blue folder. 

Tiffany & Co only provides one Diamond Certificate per ring. If your Diamond Certificate gets lost or damaged, Tiffany & Co will not replace it. 


The Tiffany & Co. Ring Box

The iconic Tiffany Blue Box is a vital part of the Tiffany experience. The color often referred to as the “robin’s egg”,  is the unique brand color of the company. It is a patented Pantone color (no. 1837 which is the year Tiffany & Co was founded). 

Every Tiffany jewelry comes with the Tiffany Blue Box. In 2022, Tiffany announced that customers purchasing engagement rings can customize the “Blue Box ”  by adding their unique lettering. 

The documentation and Tiffany blue box from your original purchase will entice any professional jewelry buyer to pay better prices when you are selling tiffany jewelry.

It will also make the new owner feel the Tiffany & Co magic that goes with the box. It would also be best if you still have the official receipt, warranty card, and information booklet. 

Can you still sell Tiffany jewelry without the accompanying paperwork and box?


If you do not have the original paperwork or packaging, you can still sell Tiffany jewelry at a great price. Take your Tiffany to an expert and reputable jewelry appraiser. 

Condition matters. Keeping your Tiffany in a good condition will give you long-term benefits, while you enjoy wearing it and  when you decide to sell it. 

Tiffany & Co offers complimentary cleaning services. You can take your jewelry to a Tiffany & Co local boutique for expert cleaning and polishing. 

However, if you are not able or choose to do this, some jewelry buyers will be able to purchase it as - is and bring the item to its best “show “ condition at a later time. 

Tiffany & Co has silver cleaning products such as Tiffany silver care kits, mitts, and polishing cloths. Jewelry cleaning products are available for every kind and type of Tiffany jewelry you own. However, the best advice we can give you is to “ give it to the experts” to evaluate, clean, polish and estimate the value of the jewelry item you want to sell.  


Where to Sell Tiffany Jewelry

A professional appraiser can expertly review your Tiffany piece to determine the materials used and its present condition to assign a value to it. You may also obtain a GIA certificate that will provide important verified details on your diamond like carats. color, clarity and cut. or you may simply find a reputable jewelry buyer who will provide an estimate of value.

You may be wondering where to sell Tiffany jewelry to get the best priceWhen selling  jewelryyou want to make sure of a few things: 

  • The party you are selling your Tiffany jewelry to, has a good reputation and is trustworthy. Do your research by reading customer reviews, find out how long the buyer is in business, do they have a physical location you can visit ? Is the staff responsive and accommodating ?  It pays to sell to a reputable and trustworthy professional jewelry buyer. Do your research. Check the jewelry buyers’ ratings from the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and check online reviews from previous clients. 
  • Ensure you understand the process and terms and timeline the payment to avoid unpleasant surprises.  


selling tiffany and co necklace
selling tiffany and co necklace is nationally known as a buying division of Gray and Sons Jewelers located in Miami, Florida. They have been in business for over 42 years. They offer the best of both worlds; brick and mortar location you can visit or you can sell online. 

Since they are rated among top jewelry retailers in the US with 3 channels of business;

Miami showroom, world class catalog and globally recognized online marketplace with hundreds of thousands of visitors per year, they are in tune with the market, newest market trends and most accurate pricing. 

They have customers looking for Tiffany jewelry and they will pay the highest price for your used, pre-owned Tiffany Jewelry. Give it a try ! 




Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer an estate jewelry, watch and sterling silver specialist with a professional career spanning over 50 years, including an impressive 30 years career at Gray and Sons Jewelers, the premier destination for selling, buying, repairing and consigning luxury watches and estate jewelry… Delve Deeper into Claudine Faifer's Full and Fascinating Story





What would you like to sell?

No Selected images
* Max. file size: 40 MB, Max. files: 5.

click here to