Sell Your Tiffany Jewelry Online Successfully

February 19th, 2026

How to Successfully Sell Your Tiffany Jewelry Online


Tiffany and Co. has some of the most well-designed and crafted pieces of jewelry in the world! If you never wear your Tiffany jewelry or need of some cash, you may want to sell tiffany jewelry.

Tiffanny & Co. Vannerie collection necklace in 18K yellow gold
Tiffanny & Co. Vannerie collection necklace in 18K yellow gold

About Tiffany & Co. 

Tiffany is one of the most beloved, iconic, and trusted brands in the jewelry industry. 

Charles Tiffany, a young New Yorker opened a stationary and fancy goods store on Broadway in the 1830s. During that time, the store was patronized by New York socialites because of its stylish fine jewelry. 

Tiffany jewelry was unique because of its modern American style making it stand out. This jewelry maker shocked the world in 1878 when it bought an amazing 200-carat yellow diamond from South Africa. 

In 1886, Tiffany & Co came up with the modern engagement ring focusing on the radiance of the diamond. Today, Tiffany engagement rings remain the most coveted branded diamond rings.

Tiffany & Co jewelry created several styles of jewelry through the years but one thing is constant – the Tiffany blue box! The robin's egg blue box is perfectly embraced by a white satin box. 

Tiffany & Co prides itself on being the highest brand of luxurious jewelry because of:

  • Brand heritage
  • Product quality
  • Lasting appeal
  • Exclusivity
  • Status
  • Feel-good factor

With an awesome history, women worldwide dream of owning a piece of jewelry from Tiffany & Co. This is good news if you want to sell tiffany jewelry

Tiffany & Co. wedding band 1837 anniversary band
Tiffany & Co. wedding band 1837 anniversary band

Tiffany Jewelry Resale Value

There are many reasons you may want to sell tiffany jewelry. 

  • Your marriage has ended and you no longer want to hold on to your engagement ring with many painful memories attached to it. 
  • You inherited a Tiffany diamond ring that does not fit your taste or style. 
  • You want to upgrade to an even better Tiffany jewelry. 

When you own Tiffany jewelry, you have a classic and popular piece! It comes with a strong resale value and is always in demand. This means you can get a good return selling tiffany jewelry. 

Why do Tiffany jewelry  retain their resale value more than any other branded jewelry? 

  • The Tiffany brand is associated with high quality, timeless design, and luxury. 
  • There is an ongoing high demand for Tiffany jewelry. 

A Tiffany engagement ring or any Tiffany jewelry that is in good condition can bring a pretty good resale value. 

Understanding the Market of Pre-Owned Tiffany Jewelry

Tiffany & Co. jewelry has a high resale value and is classic, popular, and in high demand. Tiffany jewelry is a timeless symbol of quality craftsmanship, the finest materials, and timeless designs; thus, they retain their value over time. Well-experienced master artisans cut Tiffany diamonds and are 100% conflict-free (ethically sourced). 

Tiffany & Co. engages in continuous advertising and marketing campaigns. Thus, "Tiffany" has been synonymous with luxury. As a result, your Tiffany tends to hold its resale value. A Tiffany in good condition (minimal wear and tear) can fetch top dollars in the secondary market. 

What is an Authentic Tiffany Jewelry?

When choosing to sell Tiffany jewelry, please know your piece will be evaluated if it is authentic. Tiffany & Co. is known for producing luxury fine jewelry with high-quality craftsmanship, iconic designs, and the use of precious materials. 

Look for these elements to ensure what you have is authentic Tiffany & Co. jewelry. 

Quality and Craftsmanship

Tiffany & Co. is known for its extraordinary craftsmanship and attention to detail. Authentic Tiffany jewelry exhibits high-quality construction and finishing. 

Hallmarks

Tiffany jewelry carries specific hallmarks, including the Tiffany & Co stamp, or the metal purity stamp such as "925" for sterling silver. 

Logo and Engraving

Authentic Tiffany jewelry comes with the Tiffany & Co logo or brand name and other relevant markings engraved with precision. 

Packaging and Documentation

Genuine Tiffany jewelry typically comes with original packaging (the iconic Tiffany blue box), certificates of authenticity, and receipts. 

Where to Sell Tiffany & Co Jewelry

No matter your reason for selling tiffany jewelry, you would want to get the best price possible for your piece. 

Here are some things to consider when you are ready to sell your Tiffany jewelry:

  • You want to make sure you sell tiffany jewelry to a trustworthy buyer. 
  • You want the selling process to be straightforward and hassle-free. 
  • You want to work with someone knowledgeable about the true value of your Tiffany jewelry. 
  • You want to make sure you get a fair price for your Tiffany. 

 You have some options where to sell tiffany jewelry and ensure a smooth transaction. 

  • Jewelry stores. This is a good option but since jewelry stores have a high overhead, they will offer you a lower resale value. 
  • Pawnshops. They will give you quick cash but will pay you the lowest amount for your Tiffany. 
  • Online. This is the most convenient and simplest way to sell your Tiffany. Some of the most common ways for selling tiffany jewelry online include: 

When selling tiffany jewelry online, you need to ensure you are dealing with a reputable online buyer. Here are some of your options: 

  • Online Auction House. Several online auction houses accept extremely rare and high-value Tiffany jewelry. Online auction houses are convenient but it entails high fees and a lengthy process while not guaranteeing a sale. 
  • Online Auction Sites. These sites offer user-friendly ways to list your items. However, it can be time-consuming and challenging to accurately price your item because you do not have the expertise and knowledge. 
  • Online Specialist Buyer. Online specialist buyers offer easy and quick online service for selling tiffany jewelry. These buyers can ensure you get the best price for your jewelry. 
Tiffany & Co. "True Narrow" diamond ring in 18k rose gold
Tiffany & Co. "True Narrow" diamond ring in 18k rose gold

OUR RECENT REVIEWS

How it works

ONLINE PROCESS

1. Request a Quote Find out how much is your watch or jewelry worth? The more information & photos you share with us the more accurate the market valuation will be. Upon completion of an online submission our experts will contact you with an initial quote.

2. Send Items for Inspection We will provide Easy Ship box and packing materials with our address label. Simply take it to the post office. Send it via registered mail and fully insured*, and we will refund your cost of shipping and insurance upon purchase, up to a maximum of $100, provided you submit proper documentation.

3. Receive Payment Once the inspection is complete and details of the transaction are confirmed, you will quickly receive your payment via check or bank wire.

IN-STORE PROCESS

1. Walk-In our Showroom No appointment necessary. Visit our store at 9595 Harding Avenue, Surfside, FL 33154. Across the street form world-famous Bal Harbour Shops.

2. In-House Inspection Jewelry and Watch buying experts along with in-house master trained watchmakers on-site will perform an in-house inspection for an immediate evaluation.

3. Receive Payment Once the inspection is complete and details of the transaction are confirmed, you will quickly receive your payment via check or bank wire.

* Be sure to protect your valuables with adequate shipping insurance. IF YOU OVERPAY FOR YOUR INSURANCE, IT IS NOT OUR RESPONSIBILITY TO COVER THE EXCESS AMOUNT.DO NOT USE FEDEX OR UPS, AS THEY DO NOT INSURE JEWELRY OR WATCHES.** Gray and Sons is not responsible for shipping and insurance cost to return counterfeit watches or jewelry shall the client wishes to get them returned.

What Are You Looking To Sell?

The solution to selling your jewelry
GET WATCH QUOTE

Sell your watch

How much is your watch worth?

The solution to selling your luxury watches
GET JEWELRY QUOTE

Sell your jewelry

How much is your jewelry worth?

The solution to selling your diamonds
GET DIAMOND QUOTE

Sell your diamond

How much is your diamond worth?

The solution to selling your sterling silver
GET SILVER QUOTE

Sell your sterling silver

How much is your silver worth?

What are your options?

At SellUsYourJewelry.com, we understand that selling your jewelry can be a daunting task. With SellUsYourJewelry.com, we offer flexible and convenient options tailored to your needs. Whether you’re looking to sell, trade, or consign, our process is designed to maximize the value of your luxury items. Selling to us guarantees a fast, hassle-free payout; trading allows you to upgrade or exchange your jewelry for something new; and consigning ensures you achieve the best possible price with our expert guidance. Choose the option that suits you best and enjoy unparalleled customer service and professionalism throughout the journey.

Sell your jewelry
SELL TO US
  • Fast Payment
  • Hassle-Free Process
  • Trusted Expertise
Trade in and upgrade your watch or jewelry
TRADE WITH US
  • Value Maximization
  • Price Negotiation
  • Save on Sales Tax
Consign your jewelry and watches
CONSIGN WITH US
  • Higher Returns
  • Expert Marketing
  • Risk-Free

Get your free quote

Fill out this simple form to receive a free jewelry quote!

Watch Quote Form image

GET YOUR FREE QUOTE

What would you like to sell?

â—£
No Selected images
* Max. file size: 40 MB, Max. files: 5.

GET YOUR FREE QUOTE

What would you like to sell?

â—£
â—£
No Selected images
* Max. file size: 40 MB, Max. files: 5.