Tips for Getting the Best Price: Selling to a Jewelry Buyer

March 25th, 2024

How To Get The Most Value For Selling Jewelry From A Jewelry Buyer Near Me


If you have jewelry lying around, you may be wondering “how do i  get the best value when selling my used jewelry”. The process can seem intimidating, but with the right approach, you can maximize your profits. That's where SellUsYourJewelry comes in as a top option for those looking to sell their jewelry pieces.

As specialists in buying and reselling used jewelry, SellUsYourJewelry the buying division of Gray and Sons Jewelers has extensive knowledge in pricing used jewelry, gold, silver, diamonds, gemstones, and luxury watches. We stay up-to-date with daily market fluctuations, enabling us to offer fair and competitive prices that put more cash in your pocket. Unlike pawn shops or general buyers, our exclusive focus on jewelry and watches allows us to pay top dollar, reflecting the true value of your items.

Used Diamond Bracelet in 18k for Jewelry Buyer
Used Diamond bracelet in 18k with  9 carats in full round brlliant and baguette diamonds

The company prides itself on a transparent and straightforward selling process that is safe, easy, and lucrative. You can either bring in your pieces or send pictures online for a free estimate. Our knowledgeable staff will inspect your items and provide you with a competitive offer within 48 hours. In essence, if you're looking for a hassle-free way to sell your pre-owned jewelry while maximizing your payouts, this is the way to go!

When selling used jewelry, understanding what factors determine its value is crucial to maximize your return. One key consideration is the metal type and purity - precious metals like gold, silver and platinum with higher purity will fetch better prices based on their innate worth and weight. For example, 24k gold is more valuable than 18k gold which contains other alloy metals. The current market prices for these precious metals also impact the value, so staying updated on fluctuations is important.  

The gemstones in your jewelry also play a major role - larger, higher quality precious gems like diamonds, rubies, sapphires and emeralds with excellent clarity, color and cut will significantly increase the value. However, evaluating gemstone quality requires expertise, so having professional appraisals and certifications (e.g. GIA or AGS) can substantiate the worth. Designer or brand name pieces from renowned jewelers like Tiffany, Cartier, Van Cleef & Arpels or Harry Winston hold premiums over non-branded items due to their prestige and craftsmanship standards.

Beyond the materials, the condition of your jewelry is crucial. Well-maintained pieces free of damage, deep scratches, dents or excessive wear will appraise and sell for more. Signs of proper care like polishing and protective gemstone settings are also valued. Having proper documentation like recent appraisals from accredited jewelers, grading certifications (e.g. GIA) and original packaging/boxes further verifies authenticity and value to buyers.  

Rarity and unique histories can also boost prices - vintage or antique jewelry commands higher values among collectors. Limited edition, signed pieces or those with special significance like celebrity ownership carry premiums. The collectibility and market demand for certain eras, designers or jewelry styles is also factor that can make your piece more coveted.

Used Ruby Ring ideal for Jewelry Buyer
Pre-owned AGL Certified Ruby ring with diamonds in 18k & platinum

Why Choose Sell Us Your

You may decide to cash out on your jewelry in an expedited manner. In these situations an online jewelry buyer like Sell us your jewelry can be a superior choice.  Reliability and trustworthiness are non-negotiable when entrusting your cherished jewelry to a buyer. This is where Sell Us Your stands against the


We have built a sterling reputation for reliable service. After over four decades in the business, we have become a beacon of trust for customers seeking a secure, smooth, and seamless buying experience. 

Our expertise in buying pre-owned jewelry is second to none. We have a team of seasoned professionals highly knowledgeable in the intricacies of appraisal and gemology.

Sell Us Your boasts industry recognition and 5 star customer feedback that showcases our commitment to the highest standards of ethical business practices. Our fair and transparent appraisal process ensures that seller-customers receive the true value of their jewelry. See Us Last! 

Choosing Sell Us Your Jewelry is more than just offering secure transactions; it is also about convenience and simplicity. Our straightforward selling process is as effortless as can be for our customers.

From submitting details about your jewelry online to receiving a free quote, fair appraisal, and prompt payment, our platform is designed with your ease and comfort in mind. 

Expertise, trust, and convenience work hand in hand at Sell Us Your, making us the ideal choice for those seeking a reliable partner when selling jewelry. 

The Safe Selling Process at Sell Us Your

At Sell Us Your, we have crafted a selling process prioritizing efficiency, security, and transparency. Here is a breakdown of how you can safely sell your jewelry with us.

Visit our user-friendly website and submit details about your jewelry using our simple online form. If you plan to sell a watch, our experts and master watchmakers will swiftly evaluate the information and provide a free quote. This step ensures transparency, allowing you to make informed decisions. 

Convenient Shipping 

We will give you an initial quote based on the information provided on your requested free quote form. We provide detailed instructions on how to package your jewelry safely, complete with shipping labels. Make sure to get insurance for your item. 

Thorough Appraisal

When we receive your jewelry, our expert appraisers comprehensively assess your item. We consider factors such as gem quality, metal purity, and overall condition, authenticity  and craftsmanship to determine the fair market value.

You can contact us any time through email, phone, or chat for any questions. Our transparent appraisal process and excellent customer service team are proof of our commitment to integrity and honesty.

Used Eternity Band in Yellow Gold for Jewelry Buyer
Used Eternity band with full cut round brilliant & pear shape diamonds, set in 18K yellow gold

Prompt Payment

We will send you payment once the appraisal is complete and you accept our final offer. You can choose from secure payment options, including bank transfers or checks, to receive your money quickly. 

Sell Us Your goes above and beyond to ensure your selling experience is secure, convenient, and reliable. 

Competitive Price and Fair Valuation

Sell Us Your is committed to providing competitive prices when selling jewelry, ensuring you receive the true value of your item. Our transparent valuation process is the foundation of our commitment to honesty and integrity.  

You can trust the quotes you receive from us, knowing our assessments are based on fair market values, current market trends,  and industry standards. Sell Us Your strives to offer the most money for your pre-owned jewelry. Our transactions are fast, from requesting a quote to final payment. We also do not have hidden fees. 

Used Rose Gold Hoop Earrings for Jewelry Buyer
Used 18k rose gold pave hoop earrings with round brilliant cut diamonds


Sell Us Your is a trusted name for buying pre-owned jewelry. Since 1980 as the buying division of Gray and Sons, we have served hundreds of thousands of satisfied customers who entrusted us with their jewelry and watches. 

When you are ready to sell your jewelry, Sell Us Your should be your destination. Get your free quote now!


Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer an estate jewelry, watch and sterling silver specialist with a professional career spanning over 50 years, including an impressive 30 years career at Gray and Sons Jewelers, the premier destination for selling, buying, repairing and consigning luxury watches and estate jewelry… Get insights into Claudine Faifer's life by reading more about her history.





What would you like to sell?

No Selected images
* Max. file size: 40 MB, Max. files: 5.

click here to