Sell Your Tiffany & Co. Jewelry for Lucrative Returns

May 31st, 2024

Unlock the Hidden Value: Why Selling Your Tiffany and Co. Jewelry Can Be a Lucrative Move


Since 1837, the legendary house of Tiffany & Co. has captivated the world with its exquisite jewelry creations. But the brand's origins begin with a young New Yorker named Charles Tiffany who opened a stylish stationery and fancy goods store on Broadway in 1837. Though better known today for its diamond solitaires and signature robin's egg blue packaging, Tiffany first won over New York's social elite by selling fine jewelry featuring modern American designs.

This innovative aesthetic set Tiffany apart from European jewelry of the era. By boldly acquiring a record-breaking 287-carat yellow diamond from South Africa in 1878, the brand further cemented its status as an industry pioneer catering to America's ultra-wealthy.

Building on their legacy of gemstones, Tiffany revolutionized the entire engagement ring market in 1886 by showcasing the radiant beauty of a central diamond in a six-prong setting. This iconic Tiffany® Setting became synonymous with diamond rings and weddings for generations.

Throughout its storied 185-year history, Tiffany continually broke new ground with convertible designs, enameling techniques and lavish gem-based creations flaunted by 20th century style icons. Yet one defining aspect has remained unchanged since the Victorian era - that little blue box tied with a white satin bow.

Today the Tiffany name still reigns supreme as a globally revered emblem of refined luxury, testifying to the brand's enduring allure. From dazzling diamonds to vintage Schlumberger and whimsical Elsa Peretti charms, discover why selling your used Tiffany and Co. jewelry can be a lucrative move.

Pre-owned gold Tiffany True T Narrow ring
Sell your jewelry such as your pre-owned Tiffany & Co. True T Narrow ring 18k rose gold with diamonds

Tiffany is especially renowned for their engagement rings – like Tiffany Diamond rings in platinum featuring the iconic six-prong setting. Some of Tiffany's most popular and valuable collections over the decades include:

The Schlumberger® collection: Founded by Jean Schlumberger in 1956, these statement pieces feature colorful enameling and ornate design fusing Eastern and Western aesthetics. Signatures include bib necklaces, bangles, and the Vine leaf brooch. New interpretations still focus on contrasting gems and enamel like the Flower necklace.

The Elsa Peretti® collection: Created in 1974, Peretti’s fluid, sculptural style resulted in a lexicon of openwork designs defined by movement. Quintessential pieces include the Diamonds by the Yard® necklace which paved the way for modern diamond fashion. Other iconic Peretti hits range from the bold curved Bone Cuff to the slender, stacked Diamonds by the Yard bracelet.

The Paloma Picasso® collection: Launched in 1980 with the playful Grape brooch, the line expanded to leathers and dots-and-x motifs in pieces like the Loving Heart pendant. Later came Tiffany keys inspired by Picasso’s travels. Current offerings include updated dot lines or modern pearl, onyx and wood designs

The Tiffany HardWear collection: Unveiled in 2017, this collection brings substantial chains, studs and architecturally-inspired motifs in finishes from rose gold to all-black palladium. Standouts include the gravity-defyer Ball Wire bracelet and bone-shaped Link ID bracelet.

The Tiffany T collection: Introduced in 2014, T wire bracelets paved with diamonds epitomize quiet refinement, while sleek T rings make a sharp minimalist statement. The T smile pendant and hinged T wire earrings sparked strong demand.

The Tiffany Keys collection: Modern interpretations of vintage keys and fleur-de-lis designs, seen in their ornate Fleur de Lis Key pendant with diamonds.

If you own any vintage or modern Tiffany & Co. jewelry pieces, now may be the ideal time to unlock their hidden value. The secondary market for pre-owned Tiffany jewelry is quite strong thanks to the brand's timeless designs and prestige. By selling pre owned Tiffany & Co jewelry on, you can pocket a pretty penny. Our experts specialize in accurately valuing signed Tiffany pieces based on rarity, condition, gemstone size and carat weight.

Pre-owned Tiffany & Co. necklace: diamond elegance
Discover how to sell your Tiffany jewelry, like your pre-owned Tiffany & Co. graduated diamond necklace in platinum approx 10.18 carats.

Pre-owned Tiffany Jewelry Hold its value

Unlike other luxury brands, Tiffany & Co. jewelry generally retains value over time for several key reasons. First is that Tiffany uses high-karat gold alloys and top-grade diamonds to ensure exceptional durability. That allows even vintage pieces to withstand generations of wear. And the brand's luxurious cachet lends Tiffany creations aspirational appeal as heirlooms to pass down rather than disposable fashion pieces.

Timeless pre-owned Tiffany heart pendant: Elsa Peretti's classic
Sell your Tiffany jewelry pre-owned Tiffany & Co. Elsa Peretti open heart pendant in 18k

Cut Above the Rest 

The Tiffany brand standard dictates excellence down to the cut of each gemstone they set. Their diamond specialists hand-select and cut stones to maximize radiance and life according to exacting custom specifications. No pre-cut imports or outsourced stones make it into Tiffany jewelry. This adherence to quality over convenience allows the Tiffany name to guarantee brilliance beyond industry norms.

Sell pre-owned Tiffany & Co. earrings: Angela Cumming design
How to sell Tiffany jewelry,  such as pre-owned Tiffany & Co.1999 Angela Cumming Tahitian Grey Pearls & Diamonds Earrings In 18k Gold & Platinum.

Unparalleled Craftsmanship 

Each piece of Tiffany & Co. jewelry undergoes inspection by master artisans throughout the design and production process. No detail goes unnoticed, from ensuring pristine gemstone quality to precision casting and hand-finishing precious metals. This level of expertise is unique to Tiffany creators.

Sell Tiffany Jewelry: Pre-owned T Diamond Wire Band
How to sell Tiffany jewelry,  such as pre-owned Tiffany & Co.T diamond wire band ring in 18k white gold

Seizing Seller's Market Conditions

Presently the secondary market is great for those looking to sell used Tiffany items from their personal collections. Demand for pre-owned designer jewelry continues rising significantly among shoppers. Simultaneously, acquiring top-tier luxury brands firsthand feels less accessible given inflationary prices and economic uncertainty. That underscores why selling your used Tiffany jewelry versus other jewelry brands or non branded jewelry while values climb makes  financial sense.

Get the Most for Your Pre-Owned Jewelry with

 Finding a trustworthy buyer is critical when selling used jewelry. You want assurance of fair valuations and prices. has the expertise and integrity to meet your needs.

For over 43 years, we've specialized in buying pre-owned jewelry. Our gemologists and appraisers stay current on trends and methodologies to provide accurate assessments.

Knowledge and reputation matter when selecting a jewelry buyer. With, you can trust that you’ll receive honest valuations and the highest potential offer for your pieces. Discover why we’re the premier choice for those looking to sell diamonds, gold, silver, and other pre-owned jewelry.

Preowned Tiffany gold diamond ring: timeless allure
How to sell Tiffany jewelry, such as pre-owned Tiffany & Co. diamond and ruby ring in 18k

We offer more than just secure transactions - we simplify the process. Our user-friendly online submission and free quote system is designed for your convenience. From there, we handle shipping logistics and provide comprehensive, transparent appraisals.

Expertise, trust, and ease - we bring this powerful combination to the table. Discover why we are the top choice for receiving competitive offers when selling jewelry.

Tiffany Jewelry: Sell Platinum Diamond Ring
How to sell Tiffany jewelry, such as pre-owned Tiffany & Co. 3 Stone Diamond Ring in Platinum.

Safe and Secure Selling Process

We engineered our selling process with efficiency, security, and clarity in mind. Here's what you can expect:

First, visit our website and enter your jewelry details including photos using our simple form. For Tiffany & Co Jewelry, our trained specialists swiftly evaluate submissions. This step enables informed decisions.

Next, we email a free initial quote based on the provided information. If you opt to continue, we supply an easy ship box to safely send us your item.We provide detailed instructions on how to package your jewelry safely, complete with shipping labels. Make sure to get insurance for your item. 

Upon receiving your jewelry, our on-staff gemologists and appraisers thoroughly examine it. We consider all value factors like materials, craftsmanship and condition. Contact us anytime with questions!

Once our appraisal concludes, we finalize a fair market value offer. After you accept, we process prompt and secure payment via check, bank transfer or other options.

We go beyond expectations to ensure your experience with us is seamless, convenient and rewarding. Trust our decades of experience.

Fair Prices and Valuation

Our valuation process is designed to deliver the best price for your jewelry. Our specialists thoroughly assess all relevant details and current market factors when evaluating your items.

We leverage fair market pricing, benchmark data, and the latest trends to derive fair and competitive quotes that reflect true value. You can trust our experience and methodology to maximize your payout.

Selling with us means efficiency and transparency. Expect a smooth process with no hidden fees or surprises. When you choose as your buyer, you’ll get the excellent service and top dollar your jewelry deserves.

Security and Privacy

Protecting your valuables matters to us. We implement robust security measures, so you can have peace of mind. When the time comes to sell your fine jewelry, choose a partner you can trust completely.


Sell Us Your is a trusted name for buying pre-owned jewelry. Since 1980 as the buying division of Gray and Sons, we have served thousands of satisfied customers who entrusted us with their jewelry. 

We offer a fair and transparent valuation process and provide top dollars for your jewelry. We also make prompt payments. When you are ready to sell your jewelry, Sell Us Your should be your destination. Get your free quote now!


Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer an estate jewelry, watch and sterling silver specialist with a professional career spanning over 50 years, including an impressive 30 years career at Gray and Sons Jewelers, the premier destination for selling, buying, repairing and consigning luxury watches and estate jewelry… Read more of Claudine Faifer's History in Estate Jewelry




What would you like to sell?

No Selected images
* Max. file size: 40 MB, Max. files: 5.

click here to