Sell Your Preowned Jewelry: Expert Buyer Tips Revealed

July 1st, 2024

How to Sell Jewelry without Getting Scammed, Jewelry Buyer Tips

There are many reasons you may need to sell your jewelry. You may be in urgent need of cash or need to make room for new jewelry. Finding a jewelry buyer may seem daunting, especially if you are worried about getting scammed. 

Preowned amethyst bracelet for jewelry buyers
Discover how to sell jewelry with this pre-owned Cabochon amethyst bracelet in 14k yellow gold.

Here are some tips to help you sell your jewelry with confidence:

Know the Value of Your Jewelry

Before you attempt to sell your jewelry, it is crucial to know its value. This can involve getting it appraised by a professional jeweler, appraiser or doing some research on similar pieces to gauge their market value.

Understand the Market Value

Understand your jewelry’s current market value. Prices of gold can vary daily, so keeping yourself informed with the latest market rates is essential. This knowledge helps you set realistic expectations. 

Be Realistic

Know that you may get only a partial retail value for your piece when selling jewelry secondhand. 

Prepare Your Jewelry

Take clear photographs of your jewelry from multiple angles and keep any documentation you have, such as certificates of authenticity or past appraisals. This can help establish the value of your piece and make it more attractive to buyers.

Check for Hidden Fees

Before finalizing any sale, make sure to clarify any potential hidden fees or commissions that the buyer may charge. This will ensure that you are not hit with unexpected costs after closing the sale. 

Beware of Pressure Tactics

Be cautious of buyers who use high-pressure sales tactics. A reputable jewelry buyer will give you the time and space to decide without undue pressure. Feeling rushed is a red flag and often a sign to step back and reconsider the offer.

Understand the Selling Process

Know the selling process before proceeding with selling jewelry. A trustworthy jewelry buyer will guide you through the selling process and provide transparency every step of the way. 

Make sure to understand the jewelry buyer’s payment methods, whether it is cash, check, bank transfer, or other payment platforms. When shipping your jewelry, make sure to get insurance and document the contents of your package. 

When In Doubt, Don’t 

Do not proceed with the selling process if there is something about your potential buyer or the selling process you are not comfortable with.  It is better to take your time and find the right jewelry buyer than to rush into a deal that could end up being unfavorable. As the saying goes, better safe than sorry. 

Choose Reputable Buyers’

Take the time to research potential buyers. Look for potential jewelry buyers with solid credentials, positive customer reviews, and good standings with the Better Business Bureau. Reliable and trustworthy buyers ensure a fair transaction and reduce the risk of being ripped off. 

At Sell Us Your, we understand the financial and sentimental value of your jewelry. Selling jewelry should be easy and exciting.  Thus, we offer an enjoyable and seamless process while ensuring top dollar for your jewelry. 

Besides, selling my jewelry does not have to be a risky task. Follow the tips above and confidently navigate the selling process. This way, you can maximize your profits while protecting yourself against scams. 

Preowned diamond earrings for jewelry buyers near me
pre-owned Diamond earrings in 18k white gold, perfect for jewelry buyers near me.

Sell Us Your – The Best Jewelry Buyer

Never let the fear of being scammed stop you from selling jewelry! If you are looking for the best place to sell jewelry, make sure to work with a reputable jewelry buyer- Sell Us Your

Sell Us Your, the buying division of Gray & Sons Jewelers has years of solid experience in the pre-owned jewelry market. We have been buying and selling pre-owned luxury jewelry, watches, diamonds, and sterling silver pieces since 1980. 

If you are looking for the best jewelry buyer, look no further! Sell Us Your has a team of qualified jewelers, master-trained watchmakers, and expert sales specialists with a combined experience of 150 years, ensuring you will get the most competitive offer for your precious jewelry. We make fast payments, too. 

Sell Us Your offers you three ways to sell jewelry:

  • Sell Outright

We will pay you instant cash after you accept our final offer. 

  • Consign 

We will include your jewelry in our Gray & Sons monthly catalog and all our online selling platforms. We will pay you once your jewelry gets a new owner. 

  • Trade-In

We will give you store credit equivalent to our final offer for your jewelry. You can use this store credit to buy any item from the Gray & Sons catalog.

Here is how our simple and quick selling process works.

Request a quote

Request a Quote

Request a free quote, to receive an initial offer for your jewelry. Our initial offer will be based on the photos and description you uploaded on our online form. Indicate on our form whether you opt to sell outright, consign, or trade in your jewelry.

send us your jewelry

Send Us Your Jewelry

If you are happy with our initial offer and want to proceed with the selling process, send us your item via registered mail using our Easy Ship Box. Make sure to get insurance for your package.

full jewelry inspection

Full Jewelry Inspection

When your jewelry gets to our showroom, our qualified jewelers (GIA-certified) will conduct a final assessment of it.

receive payment

Receive Payment

If you accept our final offer, we will finalize our transaction and send you immediate payment via check, wire transfer, PayPal, or Bitcoin.

Should you decide not to sell your jewelry after our final offer, a rare occurrence, we will immediately mail back your item. 

We are interested in buying any piece of jewelry from these luxury jewelry brands. 

Trust only the professionals! Trust Sell Us Your to give you the most money for your precious jewelry. We are the top luxury jewelry buyer in the United States. Ask for a free quote to know how much your jewelry is worth, and let us start the selling process! You can also visit us at 9595 Harding Avenue, Bal Harbour, Florida 33154. 



Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer: Estate Jewelry & Sterling Silver Specialist

Meet Claudine Faifer an estate jewelry, watch and sterling silver specialist with a professional career spanning over 50 years, including an impressive 30 years career at Gray and Sons Jewelers, the premier destination for selling, buying, repairing and consigning luxury watches and estate jewelry… Discover the Expertise of Claudine Faifer in Estate Jewelry




What would you like to sell?

No Selected images
* Max. file size: 40 MB, Max. files: 5.

click here to